Monday, July 25, 2011

Mainstream media coverage of e-waste issues!

Glad to see the issue is being covered in some bigger media outlets here. Unfortunately, the article barely brushes the surface of the mountains of hard-drives piling up not only in Ghana but also Senegal, Nigeria, India, China, and many other countries. It would be nice to see a piece that analyzes not only the accumulation of e-waste but also the factors and forces driving the build-up as well as possible solutions to the issues. Here, I'm thinking of stronger legislation, like the bill currently in the House but that is likely to expire when Congress goes out of session in August, but also innovative ideas that will consider the ramifications of ending e-waste dumping. One reason the informal sector is so difficult to dismantle in places like China and India is the economic value it brings to towns where the majority of income is generated through well-organized informal waste processing. Part of a solution should account for the drop in income to informal waste collectors; can a waste recovery facility provide jobs to informal waste workers while processing materials in a safer manner? This is one issue I hope to really delve into soon.

Furthermore, as rates of e-waste generation rise in developing countries, it is paramount that management systems are put into place in developing countries themselves. It is nevertheless difficult to advocate expensive waste management facilities when public services like clean drinking water and general sewage systems are not always in place. How countries, companies, and development practitioners handle this issue has serious implications for the environment and public health of tomorrow.

Ghana's e-Waste Dump Seeps Poison - Newsweek

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Quick thoughts & Updates on Federal e-waste Laws

With everything we're hearing about the debt ceiling, taxes (or lack thereof),  and the bad economy, it seems unlikely Congress will get around to discussing the Responsible Electronics Recycling Act before its session ends in August.  Granted, solving the issue of the debt ceiling in the short term and ultimately preventing American debt from continuing to grow unchecked in the long term is extremely important, no matter how we decide to go about it.  Even so, I suppose there's always hope that either house sets aside the biggest, time-sensitive issues to debate the e-Waste legislation much like they did for the incandescent light bulb last week.

Second, there's an interesting article about the impact of state e-waste recycling laws in Wisconsin and a short analysis of all stake holders' potential opinions on the 24 state laws versus a new Federal one like that which is in Congress now.  Two things are interesting to note here:


  • A Janesville, WI recycling center has added 40 additional jobs since the state passed its e-waste recycling laws.  This is a compelling argument for federal laws, especially in these economic times.  If the law is promoted from a job-creating standpoint, it may have a better chance of getting passed.  That is, if Congress gets around to actually debating it before the end of session. 
  • The article raises the point that a state-by-state patchwork of e-waste legislation raises sunk costs as electronics manufacturers comply with regulations 24 different ways across the country.  This adds to the so-called 'busy work' of e-waste recycling without increasing its efficiency.  In this light, a federal law may provide a streamlined method that reduces the costs of compliance.